Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Roanoke City Plays Real Estate Investor And Loses Again Like Usual

Photo by Jared Soares, Roanoke Times
Many of you will remember the terrible battle between Stephanie and Jay Burkholder who owned a building at 217 Reserve Avenue and the Roanoke City Government when they took it from them via eminent domain to give to Carilion.

It's easy to read a news article and think it's bad but not have sympathy for the people because you don't know them. Try to think about what you would do if this happened to you and if you would have the extra money laying around to defend yourself.  I met Stephanie a couple years ago at a Tea Party get together and these people have a heart of gold.

From what I understand, the properties "around" their flooring business, Surfaces Inc., that was located in their 217 Reserve Ave building were blighted but their building was in great shape. Apparently in the attempt to bully them out of their property, the city decided to condemn their building too which lead to a dramatic decrease in sales for their company. A very dirty and evil thing to do to a small business owner.

GIS image of the Building
All in the name of taking it and giving it to Carilion. Carilion had an agreement with the housing authority to purchase the property. Then after people started to find out about this shady deal Carilion decided to back out and said they have no use for the property. Quite possibly to attempt to maintain their image. The damage had already been done though and the Burkholders had to continue to try to save their property and business as they tried to get the message out to the public that their business was still open regardless of the condemnation.

When all was said and done, the Burkholders spent almost $600,000 on legal fees and expert witnesses to defend their property. The city spent tax payers money of over $535,000 to take it away from them.

The Burkholders hired two appraisers, one who valued the property at the time of theft (2007) at 4.83 million and the other appraised it at $4.5 million.

The jury unanimously awarded the Burkholders 2.2 million dollars. Remember it cost them over a half a million just to defend their interest in the property. And they took a major financial hit on their business which they no longer own. On May 25th 2010 they gave up the fight and did not appeal this decision.

Today the land that the Roanoke Redevelopment and Housing Authority approved a sale to Carilion Clinic who will buy the 3 acre site on Reserve avenue for 1.53 million, $670,000 less than what the tax payer paid for it. And that doesn't include the over a half a million they used of our money to take it from them.

Just wondering, can anyone think of a time where the city has made a good real estate purchase that didn't hurt the tax payer?

The Millers Hill deal turned out to be an enormous waste of tax payer money.
How about the golf course? Time will tell on that one I guess.
Or maybe the City Market Building? Lets see what the capitalization rate comes out to when the rehab is complete.

Maybe one day the city will decide that they should spend a little money hiring Real Estate Investors of Roanoke experts to help them with their deals if they are interested in buying and selling real estate. The only exception is that we are not interested in getting involved with any deal where they are stripping away someones property rights via eminent domain. Just legitimate deals is all we will help them with.

A bit of Philosophy below from the video the Philosophy of Liberty that is at the bottom of the REI home page that pertains to eminent domain. It's important to look at things from a Philosophical standpoint to determine if something is ethically and morally right or wrong.

You Own Your Own Life
To deny this is to imply that another person has a higher claim on your life than you do.

No other person or group of persons, own your Life nor do you own the lives of others.

You exist in Time:

Past, Present, Future

This is manifest in…

Life, Liberty and the product of your Life and Liberty

To lose your Life is to lose your Future, to lose your Liberty is to lose your Present

… and to lose the product of your Life and Liberty is to lose that portion of your Past that produced it

A product of you Life and Liberty is your Property

Property is the fruit of your labor, the product of your Time, Energy and Talents

Property is that part of Nature which you turn to valuable use

Property is the property of others that is given to you by voluntary exchange and mutual consent

Two people who exchange Property voluntary are both better off or they wouldn’t do it

Only they may rightfully make that decision for themselves

At times some people use Force or Fraud to take from other without voluntary consent

The initiation of Force or Fraud –

To take life is murder,

to take liberty is slavery

and to take property is theft

It is the same whether these actions are done by one person acting alone, by the many acting against the few or even by officials with fine hats

You have the right to protect your own Life, Liberty, and justly acquired Property from the forceful aggression of others

And you may ask others to help defend you

But you do not have the right to initiate force against the Life, Liberty and Property of others


Post a Comment


Real Estate Investors of Virginia. Copyright 2009 All Rights Reserved